Should You Switch? NO! (Here’s why)


From Vsauce2.

Watch my newest video, "The Auction Problem":

Thanks to Brilliant for sponsoring this video.
Birthday Paradox T-Shirt:

*** Not a real offer, for educational purposes only. I don’t have two envelopes filled with money. I don’t have any envelopes OR any money. ***

In The Two Envelopes Paradox — also called the Exchange Paradox — you know what the right answer is almost immediately. Until you don’t. And then you do. And then you’re not sure.

The problem isn’t so much the problem itself; it’s figuring out why the setup is wrong. Like several of Zeno’s Paradoxes, we’re lured into thinking about the scenario in a way that leads us down the wrong path… and by the time we realize it, we’re so deep in convincing (or troubling) math that we’ve lost sight of the real issue.

Just like with the Monty Hall Problem, even top academics have trouble elucidating clear, meaningful reasoning for why switching in the Two Envelopes Paradox is or isn’t valuable. That’s why Martin Gardner and others struggled with it for years, and why decades after the paradox (and its variants like the necktie and wallet-switching problems) debuted, it was still of academic interest in math journals and popular recreational mathematics publications.

But the Two Envelopes Paradox is an exercise in logic and probability that continues to be valuable, and probably more so than ever, with implications on how we approach math, science, and the world around us.

*** SOURCES ***

Barry Nalebuff, “The Other Person’s Envelope is Always Greener,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, Winter 1989:

Miles Mathis, “The Two Envelopes Paradox”:

Eric Bliss, “A Concise Resolution to the Two Envelopes Paradox”:

*** LINKS ***

Vsauce2 Links

Hosted and Produced by Kevin Lieber

Research And Writing by Matthew Tabor

Huge Thanks To Paula Lieber

Get Vsauce’s favorite science and math toys delivered to your door!

Vsauce Snapback Hat

Select Music By Jake Chudnow:

#learning #education #vsauce2

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Help us improve our content!

Tell us if mBlip should continue to feature this YouTuber's content.